Literature Review Matrix for Beginners: Table Your Papers, Group Studies, Find a Gap

Learning & Education

Literature Review Matrix for Beginners: Table Your Papers, Group Studies, Find a Gap

Beginner | 4 whiteboard pages · Task board: 5 columns (4 parent tasks, 12 subtasks)

Beginner: No technical terms. Just answer the whiteboard's questions, following the examples, and it takes shape.

To summarize prior research, put each paper you read on one row of a literature review matrix with five columns (author and year, aim, method, results, limitations). Reading one column from top to bottom shows which studies share a method, where results split, and which weakness keeps coming back. Then group similar studies, rank them by closeness to your question and method, and write what is known, what is not, your question, and how to test it. The same groups give you the order of sections for the literature review chapter. A mind map widens your search terms, and found papers are sorted into must read, maybe read, and on hold to fit your deadline. The examples use the smartphone use and sleep of university students. The whiteboard has four pages, and the task board has five columns with four parent tasks and three subtasks each.

0 Likes 0 Copies Author: WeProcess
prior research literature review thesis dissertation literature matrix
Sign up free and use this template

Once you have a free account, you can copy this template from the marketplace

Whiteboard preview

Read the whiteboard text as plain text

Literature Review Matrix for Beginners

How to use (4 pages): ① Write your question, widen search terms, sort papers (boards①–⑤) → ② Fill the table and find common points (boards⑥–⑨) → ③ Group similar studies and pick your question (boards⑩–⑮) → ④ Plan the writing order and meet your advisor (boards⑯–⑱)

1/4 Set your search terms

① Your research question and deadline (start here)

  • Research question (a draft is fine) e.g. How is university students' smartphone use related to sleep?
  • Deadline e.g. Hand the literature review draft to my advisor on December 1
  • Where to search e.g. The university library search and a paper search site

② Widen your search terms (from the question in ①)

  • e.g. University students, smartphones, and sleep
    • Synonyms e.g. phone, mobile phone
    • Population e.g. university students, young adults
    • What to measure e.g. sleep duration, time to fall asleep
    • Likely factors e.g. social media, staying up late
    • Technical terms e.g. smartphone use, sleep quality
    • Field e.g. psychology, public health

③ Must read

  • Papers with the words of your question in the title or abstract
  • e.g. Paper 1 - a survey of students' smartphone use and sleep
  • e.g. Paper 2 - an experiment on screen light and drowsiness
  • Start with 5. The papers you put here go into the table in ⑥

④ Maybe read

  • Papers close in either the population or the method only
  • e.g. A survey of office workers' smartphone use and work fatigue
  • e.g. An explainer on how sleep is measured
  • Read after you finish the must-reads

⑤ On hold

  • Papers that matter little now but may be useful later
  • e.g. A study of children's gaming time
  • e.g. A long review article from another field
  • Keep only the author, year, and title

2/4 Put papers in a table

⑥ Paper table (one row per paper, from the must-read pile in ③)

Author and year Aim Method Results Limitations
Paper 1 e.g. Author A (2019) e.g. Examine how phone use before bed relates to sleep time e.g. Questionnaire to 300 university students e.g. The longer the use, the shorter the sleep e.g. Surveyed one university only
Paper 2 e.g. Author B (2020) e.g. See how screen light affects drowsiness e.g. Experiment with 20 people e.g. Dimmer light helped people fall asleep sooner e.g. Small sample
Paper 3 e.g. Author C (2021) e.g. Examine how social media use relates to staying up late e.g. Questionnaire to 500 high school students e.g. People who mute notifications go to bed earlier e.g. University students not studied
Paper 4 e.g. Author D (2022) e.g. See how sleep relates to course grades e.g. Grade records and sleep diaries e.g. Shorter sleepers have lower grades e.g. Phone use was not examined
Paper 5 e.g. Author E (2023) e.g. Compare ways of measuring phone use time e.g. Compare self-reports with app logs e.g. Self-reports run about an hour a day lower e.g. Not tested on university students in Japan

⑦ Common points

  • Read the same column in ⑥ top to bottom and write what shows up in two or more papers
  • e.g. Papers 1, 3, and 4 survey many people
  • e.g. Every study points toward shorter sleep

⑧ Differences

  • Write where population, method, or results disagree
  • e.g. The population splits into university and high school students
  • e.g. Only paper 2 is an experiment that tests the effect of light directly

⑨ What is missing (from the limitations column)

  • Limitation = a weakness the study admits or a range it did not examine
  • e.g. No study looks at university students and social media use together
  • e.g. Many studies measure use time by self-report

3/4 Group similar studies

⑩ Group A (collect from the table in ⑥)

  • Collect papers from the table in ⑥ whose method or results are alike
  • e.g. Papers 1 and 3 (questionnaires to many people)
  • e.g. Finding - the longer the use, the shorter the sleep
  • e.g. Group name - studies using questionnaires

⑪ Group B

  • e.g. Paper 2 (an experiment that changed conditions)
  • e.g. Finding - dimmer screen light helps people fall asleep sooner
  • e.g. Group name - studies tested by experiment
  • A group of only one paper is fine

⑫ Group C

  • e.g. Paper 4 (the link between sleep and grades)
  • e.g. Finding - shorter sleepers have lower grades
  • e.g. Group name - studies on the effects of sleep
  • Use it to explain why your question matters

⑬ Papers that fit nowhere

  • e.g. Paper 5 (a study of how to measure use time)
  • e.g. Where to use it - when you choose your own method
  • Do not force it into a group, just note where to use it
  • When three or more alike papers pile up, make a new group

⑭ Ordering papers (closeness to your question × closeness of method)

Vertical axis: Closeness to your question / Horizontal axis: Closeness of method (could you use it too?)

  • Close question, different method e.g. Paper 2 (screen light experiment). The method differs, but use it to explain why people cannot fall asleep
  • Close question and method e.g. Paper 1 (university questionnaire) and paper 3 (high school social media). Put them at the center of the chapter and write them in most detail
  • Far question and method e.g. Paper 4 (sleep and grades). In the chapter, mention it only as background in one or two sentences
  • Close method, different question e.g. Paper 5 (comparing measurements). Use it to justify how you will measure

⑮ Decide your question (four steps from ⑨ and ⑭)

  1. What is known e.g. University students who use their phones longer sleep less (paper 1)
  2. What is not yet known e.g. Pick one from ⑨ - no study of university students looks at how social media notifications are used (paper 3 is high school)
  3. Your question e.g. Do university students who mute social media notifications before bed fall asleep faster?
  4. How to test it e.g. Ask university students by questionnaire how long it takes to fall asleep and compare by notification use. Measure use time with app logs

4/4 Set order and schedule

⑯ Order of the literature review chapter (to fit the question in ⑮)

  1. Background Why the question matters e.g. Short sleep lowers grades (paper 4 in ⑫)
  2. Group A What ⑩ found e.g. What the questionnaire studies found (papers 1 and 3)
  3. Group B What ⑪ found e.g. What the experiment found (paper 2)
  4. What is not yet known ⑨ and step 2 of ⑮ e.g. No study looks at university students and social media notifications
  5. Your question Steps 3 and 4 of ⑮ e.g. State the question and how to test it, then lead into the next chapter

⑰ Remaining papers and chapter plan (add deadlines)

Target Deadline Time needed Done when
Read e.g. 2 papers from the maybe-read pile in ④ e.g. November 10 e.g. 90 minutes per paper e.g. Rows added to the table in ⑥
Summarize e.g. Papers 1 to 5, 3 to 4 lines each e.g. November 14 e.g. 30 minutes per paper e.g. All 5 summaries are done
Write chapter e.g. All 5 steps of ⑯ e.g. November 21 e.g. 1 hour a day e.g. Drafts for all 5 steps of ⑯ are written
Review e.g. Author names and years cited e.g. November 28 e.g. 2 hours e.g. The reference list matches the text

⑱ Talking to your advisor (next step)

  • Date to meet e.g. 15 minutes after the seminar on November 12
  • What to show e.g. The table in ⑥ and the four steps in ⑮
  • What to ask e.g. Is the question the right size, and are any papers missing?

Task board contents

Not started 16 items

Set search terms

On page 1, write your research question and deadline, widen your search terms, and sort the papers you find into three piles. Once the must-read papers are chosen, move on to the table on page 2. Press Ctrl+F (⌘F on Mac) and type "3/4" to jump to page 3.

Question and date

On board ①, write your current research question (a draft is fine), your deadline, and where you will search. Done when all three notes are filled.

Expand 6 branches

On board ②, write rephrasings, the population, technical terms, and so on on the six branches, and search with them. Done when all six branches have a term and you have used them to search.

Sort into 3 piles

On boards ③ to ⑤, sort the papers you found into must read, maybe read, and on hold. Done when must read has 5 or more.

Tabulate papers

On page 2, write the must-read papers into the table one by one and pick out what they share and where they differ. This table feeds pages 3 and 4, so spend the most time here.

Fill 5 table rows

In the table on board ⑥, write one paper per row from ③, with author and year, aim, method, and results. Done when 5 rows are filled.

Fill limitations

In the limitations column of board ⑥, write the weakness the study admits or the range it did not examine. You often find it under Limitations or Future work at the end of a paper.

Find common points

Read the table on board ⑥ column by column and write common points, differences, and what is missing on boards ⑦ to ⑨. Done when each of the three frames has at least one note. ⑨ becomes the material for choosing your question on page 3.

Group studies

On page 3, group the papers in the table, arrange them, and pick your own question from what is still unknown. The question you choose here becomes the conclusion of the literature review chapter.

Form paper groups

On boards ⑩ to ⑬, collect papers whose method or results are alike. Put papers that fit nowhere on ⑬ and note where you will use them.

Rank by closeness

On the four areas of board ⑭, place papers by closeness to your question and closeness of method. Done when every area has at least one paper or you have written why it is empty.

Write your question

On the four steps of board ⑮, write what is known, what is not yet known, your question, and how to test it. Done when your question fits in one sentence.

Plan writing order

On page 4, decide the writing order of the literature review chapter, add deadlines to the remaining reading and summarizing, and set a date to talk to your advisor. Track the plan in the Reading and Writing columns of the task board.

Set writing order

On the five steps of board ⑯, line up the groups from ⑩ to ⑫ and the question from ⑮ in the order you will write them. Done when all five steps hold a board number.

Add deadlines

In the table on board ⑰, write the target and deadline for reading, summarizing, writing the chapter, and reviewing. Done when all four rows have a date.

Meet your advisor

On board ⑱, write the date, what you will show, and what you want to ask, then request a meeting with your advisor. When they reply, move the card to Shown to advisor.

Reading 0 items

Writing 0 items

Shown to advisor 0 items

Done 0 items

← Back to templates

Preview mode Literature Review Matrix for Beginners: Table Your Papers, Group Studies, Find a Gap

Whiteboard preview

① Your research question and deadline... ③ Must read ④ Maybe read ⑤ On hold ⑥ Paper table (one row per paper, fro... ⑦ Common points ⑧ Differences ⑨ What is missing (from the limitatio... ⑩ Group A (collect from the table in ⑥) ⑪ Group B ⑫ Group C ⑬ Papers that fit nowhere ⑭ Ordering papers (closeness to your ... Close question, different method Close question and method Far question and method Close method, different question ⑯ Order of the literature review chap... ⑰ Remaining papers and chapter plan (... ⑱ Talking to your advisor (next step) Literature Review... How to use (4 pag... Your question, mu... What papers say, ... Limits, what is s... Common points, in... 1/4 Set your search t... Ctrl+F / ⌘F : 2/4... → 2/4 2/4 Put papers in a t... ↙ 3/4 Research question (a draft is fine)e.g. How is university students' smartphone use related to sleep? Deadlinee.g. Hand the literature review draft to my advisor on December 1 Where to searche.g. The university library search and a paper search site ② Widen your sear... e.g. University students, smartphones, and sleep Synonyms e.g. phone, mobile phone What to measure e.g. sleep duration, time to fall asleep Technical terms e.g. smartphone use, sleep quality Population e.g. university students, young adults Likely factors e.g. social media, staying up late Field e.g. psychology, public health Papers with the words of your question in the title or abstract e.g. Paper 1 - a survey of students' smartphone use and sleep e.g. Paper 2 - an experiment on screen light and drowsiness Start with 5. The papers you put here go into the table in ⑥ Papers close in either the population or the method only e.g. A survey of office workers' smartphone use and work fatigue e.g. An explainer on how sleep is measured Read after you finish the must-reads Papers that matter little now but may be useful later e.g. A study of children's gaming time e.g. A long review article from another field Keep only the author, year, and title Author and year Aim Method Results Limitations Paper 1 e.g. Author A (2019) e.g. Examine how phone use before bed relates to sleep time e.g. Questionnaire to 300 university students e.g. The longer the use, the shorter the sleep e.g. Surveyed one university only Paper 2 e.g. Author B (2020) e.g. See how screen light affects drowsiness e.g. Experiment with 20 people e.g. Dimmer light helped people fall asleep sooner e.g. Small sample Paper 3 e.g. Author C (2021) e.g. Examine how social media use relates to staying up late e.g. Questionnaire to 500 high school students e.g. People who mute notifications go to bed earlier e.g. University students not studied Paper 4 e.g. Author D (2022) e.g. See how sleep relates to course grades e.g. Grade records and sleep diaries e.g. Shorter sleepers have lower grades e.g. Phone use was not examined Paper 5 e.g. Author E (2023) e.g. Compare ways of measuring phone use time e.g. Compare self-reports with app logs e.g. Self-reports run about an hour a day lower e.g. Not tested on university students in Japan Read the same column in ⑥ top to bottom and write what shows up in two or more papers e.g. Papers 1, 3, and 4 survey many people e.g. Every study points toward shorter sleep Write where population, method, or results disagree e.g. The population splits into university and high school students e.g. Only paper 2 is an experiment that tests the effect of light directly Limitation = a weakness the study admits or a range it did not examine e.g. No study looks at university students and social media use together e.g. Many studies measure use time by self-report 3/4 Group similar stu... → 4/4 4/4 Set order and sch... Collect papers from the table in ⑥ whose method or results are alike e.g. Papers 1 and 3 (questionnaires to many people) e.g. Finding - the longer the use, the shorter the sleep e.g. Group name - studies using questionnaires e.g. Paper 2 (an experiment that changed conditions) e.g. Finding - dimmer screen light helps people fall asleep sooner e.g. Group name - studies tested by experiment A group of only one paper is fine e.g. Paper 4 (the link between sleep and grades) e.g. Finding - shorter sleepers have lower grades e.g. Group name - studies on the effects of sleep Use it to explain why your question matters e.g. Paper 5 (a study of how to measure use time) e.g. Where to use it - when you choose your own method Do not force it into a group, just note where to use it When three or more alike papers pile up, make a new group Vertical axis: Cl... e.g. Paper 2 (screen light experiment). The method differs, but use it to explain why people cannot fall asleep e.g. Paper 1 (university questionnaire) and paper 3 (high school social media). Put them at the center of the chapter and write them in most detail e.g. Paper 4 (sleep and grades). In the chapter, mention it only as background in one or two sentences e.g. Paper 5 (comparing measurements). Use it to justify how you will measure ⑮ Decide your que... What is known e.g. University students who use their phones longer sleep less (paper 1) What is not yet known e.g. Pick one from ⑨ - no study of university students looks at how social media notifications are used (paper 3 is high school) Your question e.g. Do university students who mute social media notifications before bed fall asleep faster? How to test it e.g. Ask university students by questionnaire how long it takes to fall asleep and compare by notification use. Measure use time with app logs BackgroundWhy the question matterse.g. Short sleep lowers grades (paper 4 in ⑫) Group AWhat ⑩ founde.g. What the questionnaire studies found (papers 1 and 3) Group BWhat ⑪ founde.g. What the experiment found (paper 2) What is not yet known⑨ and step 2 of ⑮e.g. No study looks at university students and social media notifications Your questionSteps 3 and 4 of ⑮e.g. State the question and how to test it, then lead into the next chapter Target Deadline Time needed Done when Read e.g. 2 papers from the maybe-read pile in ④ e.g. November 10 e.g. 90 minutes per paper e.g. Rows added to the table in ⑥ Summarize e.g. Papers 1 to 5, 3 to 4 lines each e.g. November 14 e.g. 30 minutes per paper e.g. All 5 summaries are done Write chapter e.g. All 5 steps of ⑯ e.g. November 21 e.g. 1 hour a day e.g. Drafts for all 5 steps of ⑯ are written Review e.g. Author names and years cited e.g. November 28 e.g. 2 hours e.g. The reference list matches the text Date to meete.g. 15 minutes after the seminar on November 12 What to showe.g. The table in ⑥ and the four steps in ⑮ What to aske.g. Is the question the right size, and are any papers missing? → 2/4 Put papers in a t... ↙ 3/4 Group similar stu... → 4/4 Set order and sch...
100%

Drag to move, scroll to zoom