Project & Development
How to Find a Bottleneck for Beginners | Spot Pile-Ups by the Numbers, Fix Flow in 5 Steps
Beginner | 4 whiteboard pages · Task board: 5 columns (4 parent tasks, 12 subtasks)
Beginner: No technical terms. Just answer the whiteboard's questions, following the examples, and it takes shape.
Find your bottleneck by the numbers: line up order-to-shipping steps and see where work piles up.
Read more Show less
Write each step's daily capacity and queue, find the narrowest step, pick two ideas with the five Theory of Constraints (TOC) steps from Eliyahu M. Goldratt, and set an owner and recount day. Count every step the same way: daily capacity, items waiting, days waiting, redos. The step with the lowest daily capacity sets the pace of the whole flow, and work piles up before it. Before adding people or tools, cut its idle time.
Where 5 Whys digs into one problem's cause, this picks the step worth fixing first. For small shops and workshops with late shipping, 3 to 6 people. Filling the board takes 60-90 minutes, excluding counting days.
The board is 4 A4 pages: counting rules, numbers per step, choosing ideas, trying and recounting. The task board has 5 TOC columns, from find it to find the next, with 4 parent tasks of 3 subtasks each. Recount in about 2 weeks and reuse the board.
Once you have a free account, you can copy this template from the marketplace
Whiteboard preview
Read the whiteboard text as plain text
Bottleneck Finder for Beginners Board
How to use (4 pages): ① On page 1, note last result and agree how to count 4 numbers (boards①–③) → ② On page 2, line up the steps and write their numbers (boards④⑤) → ③ On page 3, draw ideas for the narrowest step by the 5 steps and vote for 2 (boards⑥–⑧) → ④ On page 4, set plan, daily counts, who and recount day (boards⑨–⑬)
1/4 Set the counting rules
① Last result and scope (start here)
- Result of the idea you chose last time e.g. Leave blank if this is the first round (this is the first). From round 2, write something like "After 2 weeks with Artisan A only stitching, the queue before stitching fell from 90 to 40 items"
- This round's flow and period e.g. Online orders, from order to shipping. Count for 5 days, Nov 10-14. About 25 orders a day (1 order = 1 item)
- Participants and goal e.g. 5 people: shop owner, Artisan A, Artisan B, packer, and online-order clerk. Bring shipping, now 5 days behind, back to within 2 days
② How to count 4 numbers (who/when/how)
| Who counts | When | How | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Daily capacity | e.g. Owner of each step | e.g. Every day at 5 p.m. | e.g. Items handed to the next step that day |
| Items waiting | e.g. Shop owner | e.g. Every morning at 9 a.m. | e.g. Items in the box before the step |
| Days waiting | e.g. Shop owner | e.g. Every morning at 9 a.m. | e.g. Items waiting ÷ daily capacity |
| Redo count | e.g. Whoever inspects | e.g. Every day at 5 p.m. | e.g. Items sent back to the previous step |
③ What a bottleneck is (just read)
- What a bottleneck is The narrowest step in the flow. It has the lowest daily capacity and work piles up before it. However much you speed up other steps, this step sets the speed of the whole flow. So count every step the same way and compare.
- The 5 steps of the Theory of Constraints A method (TOC) proposed by Eliyahu M. Goldratt. Think of ideas in this order - find it, use it fully, align the rest, strengthen it, find the next. Adding people or tools (strengthen it) comes 4th; first use the hands you already have without waste.
2/4 Write the numbers per step
④ Order-to-shipping steps, in one row
- Order check What the step does and who handles it e.g. Check color and engraving text of online orders, make a work ticket (online-order clerk)
- Cutting What the step does and who handles it e.g. Cut leather per the work ticket (shop owner, with help from Artisan A)
- Stitching What the step does and who handles it e.g. Punch holes and hand-stitch into shape (Artisan A and Artisan B)
- Engrave, finish What the step does and who handles it e.g. Engrave the name and polish the edges (Artisan B)
- Inspection What the step does and who handles it e.g. Check the stitching and engraved text (shop owner)
- Pack, ship What the step does and who handles it e.g. Box it, attach the shipping label, send it out (packer)
⑤ Four numbers per step and notes
| Daily capacity | Items waiting | Days waiting | Redo count | Notes | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Order check | e.g. 60 orders | e.g. 0 orders | e.g. 0 days | e.g. 1 order | e.g. Re-asking engraving text |
| Cutting | e.g. 40 items | e.g. 10 items | e.g. 0.3 days | e.g. 1 item | e.g. Tends to cut too many ahead |
| Stitching | e.g. 20 items | e.g. 90 items | e.g. 4.5 days | e.g. 2 items | e.g. Artisan A also helps cut |
| Engrave, finish | e.g. 30 items | e.g. 15 items | e.g. 0.5 days | e.g. 3 items | e.g. Polishing takes time |
| Inspection | e.g. 50 items | e.g. 5 items | e.g. 0.1 days | e.g. 4 items | e.g. Many engraving typos |
| Pack, ship | e.g. 45 items | e.g. 0 items | e.g. 0 days | e.g. 0 items | e.g. Idle after lunch |
3/4 Choose bottleneck fixes
⑥ Ideas by the 5 steps (narrowest step)
- Find it e.g. Mark stitching in table ⑤. Lowest at 20 a day, with 90 queued before it and 4.5 days waiting
- Use it fully e.g. Artisan A stops helping with cutting and only stitches
- Align the rest e.g. Cut only what stitching can handle, no more cutting ahead
- Strengthen it e.g. Packer punches the holes for 2 hours after lunch / add one workbench
- Find the next e.g. Once the stitching queue shrinks, recount in 2 weeks to find the next narrowest step
⑦ Rate ideas, 3 stamps per person
| Better flow? | Start this week? | Safe for others? | |
|---|---|---|---|
| A on stitching only | e.g. ◎ Stitching +4 a day | e.g. ◎ Can start tomorrow | e.g. ○ Shop owner alone can cover cutting |
| Cut at stitch pace | e.g. ○ Queue before stitching stops growing | e.g. ◎ Can start tomorrow | e.g. ◎ Nobody is bothered |
| Packer punches holes | e.g. ◎ Stitching +6 a day | e.g. ○ Takes 2 days to teach | e.g. ○ Packer is idle after lunch |
| Add a workbench | e.g. ○ Helps when more people join | e.g. × 3 weeks to arrive | e.g. △ Little space for it |
⑧ Chosen and skipped ideas, with reasons
- First chosen idea and why e.g. Artisan A only stitches (6 votes). Can start tomorrow and adds 4 stitched items a day
- Second chosen idea and why e.g. Packer takes over hole punching (5 votes). Adds 6 stitched items a day and uses idle hands after lunch
- Skipped ideas and why e.g. Adding a workbench (1 vote) is skipped: it takes 3 weeks to arrive and space is tight. Cutting at stitch pace (3 votes) moves to the next round
4/4 Try the ideas and recount
⑨ Plan for the 2 ideas (to first step)
- Bring shipping back to within 2 days
- Artisan A only stitches e.g. Shop owner announces it at tomorrow's morning huddle and takes over cutting
- Teach hole punching e.g. Artisan B teaches the packer for 30 minutes each Monday and Tuesday after lunch
- Set up a hole-punch spot e.g. Put a box for punched leather next to the packing table
- First step e.g. At 9 a.m. tomorrow, count the box before stitching and write it in ⑩
- Who to ask when stuck e.g. If a hole is misplaced, show Artisan B right away
⑩ 9 a.m. count of the stitching queue
- How to fill in: count as agreed in ②, then write the date and number on one line
- e.g. Nov 17, 90 items
- e.g. Nov 18, 89 items
- e.g. Nov 19, 86 items
⑪ 5 p.m. count of items stitched
- How to fill in: write the number handed to engraving and finishing that day
- e.g. Nov 17, 26 items (was 20 a day)
- e.g. Nov 18, 28 items
- e.g. Nov 19, 30 items. Getting used to hole punching
⑫ Problems (other queues, redos)
- How to fill in: write just one problem from that day
- e.g. Nov 18, hole misplaced, 2 items redone
- e.g. Nov 19, queue before engraving and finishing starts to build, 20 items
- e.g. Nov 20, shop owner's cutting was not ready by evening
⑬ Who, deadline, recount, signals
- Who and deadline Assigned to: ____ / Deadline: __/__ (month/day) e.g. Shop owner for Artisan A's change, Artisan B for hole punching. Until Nov 30
- Recount day e.g. At 9 a.m. on Dec 1, count the 6 steps again as agreed in ② and rewrite table ⑤ with the new numbers. Write the difference from the old numbers in ① of the next round
- Signals and where to go back e.g. Continue = queue before stitching is 50 or fewer. Change = 51 to 89, so change how the ideas are done. Stop = still 90 or more, so go back to (board⑦) and pick other ideas. If the queue before engraving and finishing grows bigger than before stitching, recount table ⑤ and start from box 1 of (board⑥) with the new narrowest step
Task board contents
Find it 16 items
Set counting rules
On page 1, write last round's result plus this round's flow, period, and participants, and decide who counts the 4 numbers, when, and how. Once the rules are set, everyone counts the same way on page 2. Press Ctrl+F (⌘F on Mac) and type "3/4" to jump to page 3.
Write result, scope
On the 3 notes of board ①, write last round's result for the idea you tried (blank if this is the first round), the flow and period you will look at, and the participants and goal. Done when all 3 notes are filled in.
Decide how to count
In the 12 cells of table ②, write who counts each of the 4 numbers, when, and how. Done once you have checked that everyone can count the same way.
Read the basics
Read the 2 notes of board ③ together and confirm that the narrowest step sets the speed of the whole flow, and the order of the 5 steps. Done when you have talked through every unclear point and none is left.
Write step numbers
On page 2, line up the steps from order to shipping, count the 4 numbers as agreed in ②, and write them in the table. This table is the material for picking the narrowest step on page 3.
Line up the steps
In the 6 boxes of board ④, write each step from order to shipping, what it does, and who handles it. If you have more than 6 steps, merge similar ones into 6.
Count the 4 numbers
During the period set in ①, count as agreed in ②, then fill the columns of table ⑤ for daily capacity, items waiting, days waiting, and redo count. Done when the 4 columns have no blanks.
Note observations
While counting, write what you notice, one line per step, in the notes column of table ⑤. Done when all 6 steps have a line.
Pick the fix ideas
On page 3, mark the narrowest step in table ⑤, draw out ideas with the 5 steps, compare them, and narrow to 2 ideas to try. This parent task is the heart of the board and takes most of your discussion time.
Ideas via 5 steps
In the first box of board ⑥, write the narrowest step; in boxes 2 to 5, write one idea per step aimed at that step. Done when all 5 boxes are filled.
Vote on 3 criteria
Write 4 of the ideas from ⑥ in the rows of table ⑦, fill the 3 criteria columns, then each person places 3 circle stamps as votes. Done when everyone has placed their votes.
Write picks and why
Pick the 2 ideas with the most votes. On the notes of board ⑧, write each chosen idea and why, and the skipped ideas and why. Done when all 3 notes are filled in.
Try ideas, recount
On page 4, set the plan and the person in charge for the 2 chosen ideas, try them for 2 weeks while writing the numbers every day, and recount on the decided day. Write the recounted result in ① of the next round.
Set plan and owner
On the branches of board ⑨, write the plan for the 2 ideas chosen in ⑧ down to the first step, and on board ⑬ write who is in charge, the deadline, and the recount day. Done when the assigned-to and deadline fields of ⑬ are filled in.
Log daily counts
During the 2 weeks of trial, write one dated line each day - the morning queue on board ⑩, the number stitched in the evening on board ⑪, and trouble on board ⑫. Done when you have 2 weeks of entries.
Decide by signal
On the recount day, compare the recounted numbers with the signals on board ⑬ and decide to continue, change, or stop. Done when the decision and why are added to the signal note in ⑬. If you stop, go back to table ⑦.