Project & Development
Fishbone Diagram (Cause and Effect) for Beginners | Sort Causes by 4M, Pick What to Check
Beginner | 4 whiteboard pages · Task board: 5 columns (4 parent tasks, 12 subtasks)
Beginner: No technical terms. Just answer the whiteboard's questions, following the examples, and it takes shape.
Fishbone diagram: state a problem in numbers, sort causes by 4M, pick what to check first.
Read more Show less
Write the problem as a number such as 8 a month, with when and where it happens. Put causes on sticky notes for each bone: People, Method, Machine, Material. Add Measurement (how you count and record) and Environment (lighting, time of day) to catch causes that fit no bone, then pick one cause per bone. Compare the six on impact, ease of checking, and fact or guess, and vote with three dots each. Unlike 5 Whys, which digs down one cause, this spreads wide first and then narrows, so you are less likely to jump to an assumed cause.
Plan for 5 to 8 people and 60 to 90 minutes in one meeting. The example follows a pickle factory line where label mix-ups rose to 8 a month.
The whiteboard has four pages: set the problem, list causes, choose factors, check and act. The task board has five columns with 4 parent tasks and 12 subtasks.
Once you have a free account, you can copy this template from the marketplace
Whiteboard preview
Read the whiteboard text as plain text
Fishbone Diagram Board with Four Bones of Causes
How to use (4 pages): ① Write the purpose and set the problem in numbers (boards①–③) → ② List causes bone by bone (boards④–⑧) → ③ Compare on 3 criteria and vote on what to check (boards⑨⑩) → ④ Decide checks, fixes, and a signal (boards⑪–⑬)
1/4 Set a problem in numbers
① Purpose, time, people (start here)
- Purpose of the meeting e.g. Find the causes of the packaging label mix-ups that rose from October, then decide the order of checks and countermeasures
- Time today e.g. Thursday after the lunch break, 60 minutes next to the packaging area
- Who takes part e.g. 6 people on the line (1 team leader, 3 on packaging, 2 on filling)
② The four bones of a fishbone diagram
- Problem (effect)
- People Causes about people, such as duty, experience, or headcount. e.g. New hires have not learned where the label shelf is
- Method Causes in steps, rules, or order. e.g. No tidy-up rule when switching products
- Machine Causes in tools, equipment, or settings. e.g. The label printer screen is small
- Material Causes in items, parts, or labels used. e.g. Two similar-colored labels exist
③ One-line problem in numbers and facts
- The problem in one sentence e.g. Packaging labels are mixed up 8 times a month
- How the count changed e.g. 1 to 2 a month through September. 8 in October
- When it happened e.g. 6 of the 8 happened after 3 p.m.
- Where it happened e.g. All 8 on packaging line 2, 5 of them right after a product switch
2/4 List causes by bone
④ People bone (causes of ③)
- How to fill in: write what could happen from duty, experience, headcount, or speaking up, one per note
- e.g. Two new hires from October do not yet know where the labels are shelved
- e.g. The team leader is away from packaging on other work at times
- e.g. Tired from standing in the afternoon, people rush the check after sticking labels
⑤ Method bone (steps, rules)
- How to fill in: write what could happen from steps, rules, and work order
- e.g. Similar-named products (mild pickles and low-salt mild pickles) are packed back to back on one day
- e.g. No rule to clear leftover labels when switching products
- e.g. Checking after sticking is by eye only and not recorded
⑥ Machine bone (tools, equipment)
- How to fill in: write what could happen from tools, equipment, and settings
- e.g. The label printer screen is small and the chosen product name is hard to read
- e.g. The product order changed after the printer settings were swapped in October
- e.g. When the packing machine stops, work switches to sticking by hand
⑦ Material bone (items used)
- How to fill in: write what could happen from labels, containers, and purchased items
- e.g. The new labels are light green and yellow-green, which look alike
- e.g. The container supplier changed in October and the lid shape is slightly different
- e.g. Label bundles have no product-name tag
⑧ Top cause per bone (six in all)
| Most worrying cause | Why you think so | Who knows more | |
|---|---|---|---|
| People | e.g. Two new hires do not know the shelf location | e.g. Three cases on the duty days of the two October hires | e.g. Team leader |
| Method | e.g. Old labels are not cleared at a switch | e.g. 5 of 8 right after a switch | e.g. Packaging staff on line 2 |
| Machine | e.g. The printer's product order changed | e.g. Same timing as the October settings swap | e.g. Equipment owner |
| Material | e.g. Two similar-colored labels exist | e.g. Mix-ups seem frequent between the same two kinds | e.g. Office staff who order labels |
| Measurement | e.g. Pre-shipment checks are not recorded | e.g. Counts up to September are from memory | e.g. Team leader |
| Environment | e.g. The packaging area is dim in the afternoon | e.g. 6 of 8 happened after 3 p.m. | e.g. Packaging staff on line 2 |
3/4 Pick the key factors
⑨ Rate 6 causes (up to 3 dots each)
| Cause (copy from ⑧) | Impact (1-5) | Easy to check (1-5) | Fact or guess | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| People | e.g. New hires do not know the shelf location | e.g. 3 | e.g. 4 | e.g. Guess (it only overlaps their duty days) |
| Method | e.g. Old labels are not cleared at a switch | e.g. 5 | e.g. 5 | e.g. Fact (5 of 8 right after a switch) |
| Machine | e.g. The printer's order changed | e.g. 4 | e.g. 3 | e.g. Guess (only the timing matches) |
| Material | e.g. Two similar-colored labels exist | e.g. 4 | e.g. 5 | e.g. Guess (reviewing the 8 cases can confirm it) |
| Measurement | e.g. Pre-shipment checks are not recorded | e.g. 2 | e.g. 5 | e.g. Fact (there is no record sheet) |
| Environment | e.g. The afternoon lighting is dim | e.g. 3 | e.g. 2 | e.g. Guess (afternoon fatigue overlaps too) |
⑩ Check or skip, with reasons
- Factor to check (1st) and why e.g. On the Method bone, "Old labels are not cleared at a switch". It has 5 dots and the fact that 5 of 8 came right after a switch
- Factor to check (2nd) and why e.g. On the Material bone, "similar-colored labels". It has 4 dots, and reviewing the mixed-up pairs among the 8 cases can confirm it in 2 days
- Factor to skip and why e.g. On the Environment bone, "lighting". It has 1 dot, and changing the lighting needs a factory-wide discussion, so we skip it this time
4/4 Check and take action
⑪ How to check and fix the ⑩ factors
- The 2 factors chosen in ⑩
- Check (switching) e.g. The team leader checks every box from 30 minutes before to 30 minutes after a switch / line up switch times with mix-up times
- Fix (switching) e.g. Put the old labels back in the box / two people read the product name aloud / mark a switch sheet
- Check (label color) e.g. Count the mix-ups of similar colors among the 8 / compare the two kinds side by side from a distance
- Fix (label color) e.g. Tag each bundle with the product name / store them on separate shelves / order labels in different colors
⑫ The number before fixes and who counts
- The number before fixes e.g. 8 a month in October (about 4 in two weeks)
- Who counts and when e.g. The team leader writes the day's count on the record sheet at the end of each day's work
- How to count e.g. Count separately what pre-shipment checks catch and what stores report
⑬ Owners, deadlines, go-back signals
| Action | Owner | Deadline | How to check | Signal and go-back | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Check | e.g. Look at every box from 30 minutes before to 30 minutes after a switch. Also count the color pairs of the 8 cases | e.g. Team leader | e.g. By Nov 8 | e.g. Write the count on the ⑫ sheet | e.g. If 5 days turn up no case at all, go back to (board⑨) |
| Fix (method) | e.g. At each switch, put old labels back in the box and read aloud in pairs | e.g. Packaging staff on line 2 | e.g. Two weeks from Nov 11 | e.g. Count at the end of each day | e.g. Continue if 1 or fewer in 2 weeks, change if 2 to 3, go back to (board⑨) if 4 or more |
| Fix (material) | e.g. Tag the label bundles and put the two similar colors on separate shelves | e.g. Office staff who order labels | e.g. By Nov 15 | e.g. Count mix-ups of the same pair | e.g. If the same pair shows up within 2 weeks, change the placement; if it still does, go back to (board⑨) |
Task board contents
Define the problem 16 items
Quantify the problem
On page 1, write the purpose and who takes part, then settle the problem to discuss in one sentence with numbers and facts. Once the problem is one sentence, the cause-listing on page 2 aims at the same target. Press Ctrl+F (⌘F on Mac) and type "3/4" to jump to page 3.
Note purpose, people
On the three sticky notes of board ①, write the purpose of the meeting, today's time, and who takes part. Done when all three are filled.
Read the four bones
Read the fishbone on board ② together and agree what kinds of causes go on the People, Method, Machine, and Material bones. Done when, for any bone you do not follow, someone can give one example on the spot.
Write the problem
On the four sticky notes of board ③, write the one-sentence problem, how the count changed, when it happened, and where. Done when the count and the place are written.
List causes by bone
On page 2, list causes on sticky notes for each of the four bones about the problem in ③, then add Measurement and Environment and pick one cause that bothers you from each of the six bones. The more you list here, the more you have to compare on page 3.
People and Method
On boards ④ and ⑤, each person silently writes two or more cause notes, then sticks them up. Stack similar notes together; done when no more come.
Machine and Material
On boards ⑥ and ⑦, stick up cause notes the same way as on ④ and ⑤. Done when both bones have three or more notes.
Pick one per bone
In the table on board ⑧, write the cause that bothers you most for each of the six bones, why you think so, and who knows more. No notes were made for the Measurement (how you count and record) and Environment (lighting, time of day) rows, so think and write them here for the first time. Done when all six rows are filled.
Pick key factors
On page 3, compare the six causes from ⑧ on three criteria and narrow them to at most two factors to check. There is no time to check everything, so deciding the order here is the shortcut to countermeasures.
Copy six causes
Copy the six causes from ⑧ into the left column of the table on board ⑨, and write impact and ease of checking as numbers from 1 to 5 (5 is biggest and easiest). Done when the fact or guess column is also filled.
Vote with 3 dots
In the table on board ⑨, each person puts up to three red dot stamps on the rows of the causes they want to check. Done when everyone has placed theirs and you have counted the dots.
Write why you chose
On board ⑩, write the two factors to check and why, and the factors you skip and why. Done when you can state the reason for skipping in one sentence.
Check and act
On page 4, decide the checks and countermeasures for each factor chosen in ⑩, and write owners, deadlines, and a signal to continue or go back. Track what you decide in the Checking column of the task board.
Widen checks, fixes
On the mind map of board ⑪, write two or more ideas for checks and countermeasures for each chosen factor, separated by "/". Done when all four branches have two or more ideas.
Set count and owners
On board ⑫, write the count before countermeasures, who counts, and how. In the table of board ⑬, write the actions chosen from ⑪ with owners and deadlines. Done when the owner and deadline columns of ⑬ are filled.
Decide on a signal
Two weeks later, look at the "Signal and go-back" column of board ⑬ and decide to continue, change, or stop. Done when the decision is written in that column; when you stop, go back to board ⑨ and pick the next factor.