Business & Strategy
Value Proposition for Beginners | Match a customer's problems to your offer, then write one line
Beginner | 4 whiteboard pages · Task board: 5 columns (4 parent tasks, 12 subtasks)
Beginner: No technical terms. Just answer the whiteboard's questions, following the examples, and it takes shape.
Build a value proposition: match a customer's problems to your offer and write one line.
Read more Show less
Pick one of three candidate customers, list their problems and wishes in their own words, and line up which parts of your product answer the top four. Mark unanswered problems and unwanted parts, then pick up to three fixes by weight and ease. Finally, write one line in the form: in this situation, what used to bother me now changes like this, so I chose it.
It checks whether your product answers a customer's problems, not how it differs from rivals. Small shops and sole proprietors launching a product can use it alone or in a team of two to four. Allow two to three hours for the table and the line; asking three customers happens on another day.
The whiteboard has 4 pages (pick one customer, match voices to your offer, choose fixes and the line, fix and check) and 15 frames with examples. The task board has 5 columns, 4 parent tasks and 12 subtasks.
Once you have a free account, you can copy this template from the marketplace
Whiteboard preview
Read the whiteboard text as plain text
Value Proposition Board for Beginners (One Line in Your Customer's Words)
How to use (4 pages): ① Page 1: write the goal, pick one customer (boards①–⑤) → ② Page 2: list problems, wishes and your offer, match them in a table (boards⑥–⑨) → ③ Page 3: choose the gaps to fix and the value line (boards⑩–⑫) → ④ Page 4: fix them and check with 3 customers (boards⑬–⑮)
1/4 Pick one customer
① Goal, date, who joins (start here)
- What you will launch and want to check (goal) e.g. Check whether the weekday lunch takeaway set starting in December (by reservation, $4.50 a meal) answers the problems of people working at nearby companies
- Date you finish checking e.g. November 25. Fix what needs fixing before reservations open on December 1
- Who thinks it through with you e.g. The owner, the owner's daughter and two part-timers, four people. One hour after closing, over three days
② Line up 3 candidates, pick 1
| Who they are | When they use it | How they cope now | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Candidate A | e.g. Office worker in their 30s at a company by the station, with a 45-minute lunch break | e.g. Eats at their desk on weekday noons | e.g. A convenience-store lunch, after waiting in the register line |
| Candidate B | e.g. Field salesperson in their 40s | e.g. Eats in the car between visits | e.g. A beef-bowl shop, done in 10 minutes |
| Candidate C | e.g. The person who orders meeting lunches at a company | e.g. Orders for 10 people twice a month | e.g. Phones a caterer by the next station |
| The one you pick | e.g. Candidate A | e.g. Most of the people who pass the shop every day are like this | e.g. The short lunch break is a clear problem |
③ What a value proposition is (read)
- How to fill in: the reason a customer gives for choosing you ("so I chose this"), written as one line in the words customers use. That line is called the value proposition (the value that makes customers choose you)
- e.g. Words from the shop: handmade lunch set made with locally grown rice
- e.g. Words from the customer: I can pick it up without waiting in line, and it has vegetables
④ The two things you match (read)
- How to fill in: put the customer problems and wishes and what your product contains in the same table, and check one by one which part answers which
- e.g. Problem: waiting in the register line takes 10 minutes off my lunch
- e.g. Offer: reserve the day before and pick up by just giving your name
⑤ Red: the 2 gaps to fix (read)
- How to fill in: matching turns up two kinds of gap: a problem nobody answers, and a part of the product nobody wants
- e.g. Problem nobody answers: not enough vegetables (nothing with vegetables)
- e.g. Part nobody wants: the points card (nobody asked for it)
2/4 Match voices to your offer
⑥ Red: Problems (from the one in ②)
- How to fill in: write, one at a time, what bothers the person chosen in ②, in words they would say
- e.g. Waiting in the register line cuts 10 minutes from my lunch
- e.g. It is all fried food, and I feel I am short on vegetables
- e.g. By the time I carry it back to my desk, the rice has gone cold
⑦ Green: Wishes (what ② would love)
- How to fill in: write, in their own words, what would please the person in ②
- e.g. I want hot rice at my desk at the office
- e.g. Different side dishes every day so I never get bored
- e.g. Less time spent deciding what to eat at lunch
⑧ Gold: Your offer (the set today)
- How to fill in: write one by one what your product contains now, such as price, how it is picked up and the side dishes
- e.g. Reserve by 5 p.m. the day before, pick up at 11:45
- e.g. Three side dishes that change daily, $4.50 per meal
- e.g. Handmade with locally grown rice, and a points-card discount after 10 reservations
⑨ Match table (top 4 from ⑥⑦, offer ⑧)
| Problem or wish | Part that answers | How it answers | Mark (★ = gap) | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Top 1 | e.g. Waiting in line cuts 10 min from lunch | e.g. Reserving the day before | e.g. Pick up by just giving your name | e.g. Answered |
| Top 2 | e.g. Not enough vegetables | e.g. None | e.g. Side dishes are mostly fried | e.g. ★ Not answered |
| Top 3 | e.g. Want hot rice at my desk | e.g. Pickup at 11:45 | e.g. Goes cold 30 minutes after packing | e.g. ★ Not answered |
| Top 4 | e.g. Want different dishes every day | e.g. Three daily dishes | e.g. Different dishes on all 5 weekdays | e.g. Answered |
| Part matching none | e.g. None (nobody listed it) | e.g. Points card, handmade with local rice | e.g. Does not appear in the customer's words | e.g. ★ Nobody wants it |
3/4 Choose fixes and the line
⑩ Place ⑨'s ★ gaps (3 votes each, up to 3)
Vertical axis: How heavy for the customer / Horizontal axis: How easy to fix by launch day
- Heavy, hard to fix e.g. None in this example. A heavy, hard gap that needs someone to deliver it goes after launch day
- Heavy, easy to fix Pick from here first, up to 3. e.g. Not enough vegetables / Cold at pickup
- Light, hard to fix e.g. Nobody cares about handmade local rice (redoing the sign waits until after December)
- Light, easy to fix If the top right has fewer than 3, pick from here too. e.g. The points card (just stop making it)
⑪ Compare 3 draft lines on the criteria
| Draft value line | In customer words? | Hits a top problem? | True once fixed? | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Draft A | e.g. On a short-lunch day, a cold lunch after waiting in line becomes a hot lunch with vegetables at 12:00, so I chose this | e.g. ○ Words from ⑥⑦ | e.g. ○ Top 1, 2 and 3 | e.g. ○ The side dish and 12:00 pickup make it true |
| Draft B | e.g. When I choose lunch, because it is handmade with local rice, I chose this | e.g. × Words from the shop | e.g. × Hits none of them | e.g. ○ True with today's offer |
| Draft C | e.g. On a day I cannot decide, the same dishes in a row become a different dish each day, so I chose this | e.g. ○ Words from ⑦ | e.g. △ Top 4 only | e.g. ○ Three daily dishes make it true |
⑫ Chosen and why / set aside and why
- Gaps you chose and why e.g. Not enough vegetables, cold at pickup and the points card. They got the most circles and can be fixed by December 1
- Value line you chose and why e.g. Draft A. It is in the customer's words and hits three top problems
- Gaps and line you set aside, and why e.g. Pushing the handmade local rice (nobody cares, and redoing the sign waits until after December). Draft B (in the shop's words, hits no problem)
4/4 Fix and check with customers
⑬ Fix the 3 gaps and line (owner, date)
| What to fix | Owner | Deadline | Done when | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fix 1 | e.g. Add a vegetable side dish each day | e.g. The owner | e.g. November 18 | e.g. Side dishes added to 5 days of menus |
| Fix 2 | e.g. Move pickup to 12:00 and start packing at 11:50 | e.g. Daughter | e.g. November 18 | e.g. A test pack was still hot at 12:00 |
| Fix 3 | e.g. Stop making the points card | e.g. One part-timer | e.g. November 15 | e.g. The print order is cancelled |
| Rewrite the line | e.g. Rewrite the line of Draft A to match the fixed offer | e.g. Daughter | e.g. November 19 | e.g. The line and menu are on one sheet of paper |
⑭ Ask 3 customers (in person, on paper)
- Prepare Write the fixed offer and the line on one sheet e.g. Print 3 copies of the line from ⑬ and the 5-day menu with the side dish
- Show Show it to 3 office workers who visit e.g. On Nov 20, 24 and 25 at lunch, speak to office workers passing the shop and hand each one a sheet
- Listen Have them say when they would use it and why e.g. Do not read the line out; ask when they would use it, and why
- Write down Put what they say on ⑮ as is e.g. Write it on a note exactly as heard, with no rewording
⑮ What they said and the signals
- What they said (3 people) e.g. "If I can pick up something hot at 12:00, even every day" "I like that it has vegetables" "Maybe not on meeting days"
- Signals and where to go back (continue, change, stop) e.g. If 2 or more of 3 give the same reason as the line, continue. If only 1 does, restate the line (change). If none does, drop this line and go back to (board⑨)
- What you decided e.g. Continue. From December 1, tell customers the line of Draft A on a sheet in front of the shop and on reservation calls
Task board contents
Decide 16 items
Pick one customer
On page 1, write the goal and the date you will finish checking, then pick one of three candidate customers. Once you have one, pages 2 on can be written in that person's words only. Press Ctrl+F (⌘F on Mac) and type 3/4 to jump to page 3.
Set goal and date
On the three notes of board①, write the product you will launch and what you want to check, the date you will finish checking, and who thinks it through with you. Done when all three are filled.
List 3 candidates
In the rows for candidates A to C in the table of board②, write who they are, when they use it and how they cope now. Done when the last row has the one you chose and why.
Read about the gaps
Read boards③–⑤ and make sure you understand what the value line means, the two things you match and the two gaps you fix. Done when no word is unclear.
Match voice to offer
On page 2, list the chosen customer's problems and wishes and what your product contains, match them in a table, and mark the gaps. This is the heart of the template and takes the most time.
Problems and wishes
On boards⑥ and ⑦, add the problems and wishes the person chosen on board② would say, in their own words, one per note. Done when each has three or more.
List what you offer
On board⑧, write what your product contains now, such as price, how it is picked up and the side dishes, one per note. Done when you have written everything you can think of.
Build match table
In the table on board⑨, write the top four by weight, the part of the product that answers each and how, and in the last row the parts that match none. Done when the gap rows have a star.
Pick fixes and line
On page 3, choose up to three gaps to fix from the ones you marked, and pick one of three draft value lines. What you choose here is what you fix on page 4.
Plot gaps and vote
Place the starred gaps from board⑨ on the chart on board⑩ and give each person three votes as circles. Done when you have chosen up to three gaps with the most circles.
Compare 3 drafts
In the table on board⑪, write three drafts of the value line and mark each with ○, △ or × for being in the customer's words, hitting a top problem and holding true with the fixed product. Done when all three columns are filled for all three drafts.
Write your reasons
On board⑫, write the gaps and the line you chose with reasons, and the gap and line you set aside with reasons. Done when the three notes are filled.
Fix and check
On page 4, give each chosen fix an owner and a deadline, then show the fixed product and the value line to three customers and check. Track it in the Fixing column of the task board and move it to Checked with customers when you have heard them all.
Assign the fixes
In the four rows of the table on board⑬, write what to fix, who does it, by when, and what counts as done. Done when all four rows have an owner and a deadline.
Ask 3 customers
Following board⑭, write the fixed product and the line on paper, show it to three customers, and write what they said word for word on the first note of board⑮. Done when you have the words of three people.
Decide go or stop
Look at the signals on board⑮ and decide whether to continue, change or stop. Done when you have written what you decided and the next step on the third note of board⑮.