Business & Strategy
Payoff Matrix for Beginners | Plot Ideas by Impact and Effort, Then Pick 3 to Do This Month
Beginner | 4 whiteboard pages · Task board: 5 columns (4 parent tasks, 12 subtasks)
Beginner: No technical terms. Just answer the whiteboard's questions, following the examples, and it takes shape.
The payoff matrix sorts ideas by impact and effort to pick this month's top three.
Read more Show less
A team picks the three to do this month, with owners. Ideas fall into four groups: do now, plan it, fit it in, and skip. First agree, with examples, what high, medium, and low impact and effort mean. Then place every idea, give each person three votes, and set an owner and deadline. A shared scale shows which ideas people place differently, so discuss only those and record the final spot and why.
This is not the payoff matrix of game theory, but an impact-and-effort table. Each pick gets a continue, change, or stop signal, checked a month later. It suits 4 to 7 people and 60 to 90 minutes, and each meeting starts with last time's results, so the scale fits your work better each round.
The board has four A4 pages: set the scale, place ideas, pick three, hand them to owners. The task board has 5 columns, 4 parent tasks (one per page), and 12 subtasks.
Once you have a free account, you can copy this template from the marketplace
Whiteboard preview
Read the whiteboard text as plain text
Payoff Matrix Board for Beginners
How to use (4 pages): ① Write last results and ideas, align the scale (boards①–⑥) → ② Place all ideas, discuss split ones (boards⑦–⑩) → ③ Compare candidates, vote 3 each, pick this month's three (boards⑪⑫) → ④ Set owner, deadline and signal for each (boards⑬–⑮)
1/4 Align the scale
① Last results, goal, who (start here)
- Results of last time's three e.g. Blank is fine the first time
- Purpose this time e.g. From the 20 ideas raised at the monthly improvement meeting, choose the 3 to do this month
- Attendees e.g. Six people: plant manager, 2 sales, 2 prepress, 1 delivery
② Ideas: from the meeting
- How to fill in: one idea per note. Add a letter and write it as an action
- e.g. A Make a proof-check sheet
- e.g. B Cut the morning huddle by 5 minutes
- e.g. C Set a press-cleaning rota
③ Ideas: from customer feedback
- e.g. D Reply to quotes the same day
- e.g. E Redo every delivery note format
- e.g. F Accept business card proofs by email too
- e.g. Source of D: 3 comments last month said quotes are slow
④ Ideas: from problems on the floor
- e.g. G Color-code paper shelves by type
- e.g. H Share delivery routes on a map
- e.g. I Buy a new plate-setter
- e.g. J Standardize prepress file names
⑤ Impact and effort scale, with examples
| Impact (gain) | Effort (time, cost) | Shop example | |
|---|---|---|---|
| High | e.g. Cuts reprints or complaints by 3 or more a month | e.g. Over a month of work, or costs $700 or more | e.g. I New plate-setter (high impact, high effort) |
| Medium | e.g. Cuts 1 to 2 a month, frees 1+ hour a week | e.g. 2 to 3 people for about 2 weeks, under $700 | e.g. J Standardize file names (medium impact, medium effort) |
| Low | e.g. A little easier, under 1 a month | e.g. 1 person within 1 day, no cost | e.g. C Cleaning rota (low impact, low effort) |
⑥ The table and 4 spots (read only)
- What is an impact-effort table For each idea, estimate how much it improves things (impact) and how much people, days, or money it takes (effort), then sort it into one of four spots, impact up and effort across, and decide what to start first. Also called a payoff matrix (not the same as the game-theory payoff matrix)
- What the 4 spots mean Do now = high impact, low effort. Plan it = high impact, high effort. Fit it in = low impact, low effort. Skip = low impact, high effort. For a medium idea, use the scale in ⑤ to decide which side it is closer to
2/4 Place ideas on two axes
⑦ Place all ideas from ②–④ (matrix)
Vertical axis: Impact (top = high, bottom = low) / Horizontal axis: Effort (left = low, right = high)
- Do now (high impact, low effort) e.g. B shorter huddle / D same-day quotes / F proofs by email / G shelf colors. Page 3 picks up to 3 from here
- Plan it (high impact, high effort) e.g. I new plate-setter. Not picked this month; pass it to ⑭ on page 4
- Fit it in (low impact, low effort) e.g. C cleaning rota. Whoever is free picks it up
- Skip (low impact, high effort) e.g. E redoing delivery notes. The current format causes no trouble, so leave it this month
⑧ Impact estimates that split (from ⑦)
- How to fill in: write the idea, then the reasons of those who rated it high and low
- e.g. A Make a proof-check sheet
- e.g. Prepress: "Cuts 3 reprints a month, so high impact"
- e.g. Sales: "Few complaints, so medium impact"
⑨ Effort estimates that split (from ⑦)
- e.g. H Share delivery routes on a map
- e.g. J Standardize prepress file names
- e.g. Delivery: "Just load it into a map app, so low effort"
- e.g. Plant manager: "Entering 20 customers takes over a month, so high effort"
⑩ Spots and reasons decided for ⑧⑨
- Ideas decided as do now e.g. A Proof-check sheet. One reprint wipes out paper cost and half a day's work, so we called it high impact
- Ideas decided as plan it e.g. H Delivery routes. Entering 20 customers takes over a month, so it goes to next month or later
- How we decided e.g. J File names are medium effort, so it goes in do now. If we still disagree after talking, the plant manager decides and writes the reason
3/4 Pick this month's three
⑪ Compare ⑦⑩ do-now ideas (3 votes each)
| Impact level | Effort level | Done this month? | Votes | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A Proof sheet | e.g. High (decided in ⑩) | e.g. Medium | e.g. Yes (2 weeks) | e.g. 5 votes |
| B Shorter huddle | e.g. Medium | e.g. Low | e.g. Yes (1 day) | e.g. 1 vote |
| D Same-day quotes | e.g. High | e.g. Low | e.g. Yes (make a template) | e.g. 6 votes |
| F Email proofs | e.g. Medium | e.g. Low | e.g. Yes (1 day) | e.g. 2 votes |
| G Shelf colors | e.g. Medium | e.g. Low | e.g. Yes (half a day on a day off) | e.g. 3 votes |
| J File names | e.g. Medium | e.g. Medium | e.g. Half done | e.g. 1 vote |
⑫ This month's 3 and why / set aside
- The 3 picked and why e.g. D same-day quotes (6 votes, many customer comments), A proof-check sheet (5 votes, fewer reprints), G shelf colors (3 votes, done in half a day)
- Ideas set aside and why e.g. J file names would only be half done this month, so they are a candidate for next month. B and F got only 1 to 2 votes and were set aside
- When votes tie e.g. Pick the one with lower effort. If still tied, the plant manager decides
4/4 Hand three to owners
⑬ First step for ⑫'s 3 and shared prep
- This month's 3
- D Same-day quotes e.g. Sales makes one quote template
- A Proof sheet e.g. Prepress writes down 5 causes of reprints
- G Shelf colors e.g. Delivery counts the paper types
- Shared prep e.g. Tell everyone the 3 and owners at Monday's huddle
⑭ Ideas for later (plan it, set aside)
- Ideas for next year e.g. I New plate-setter. Get a quote for next year's budget talks
- Ideas for next month e.g. H Delivery route map. Paste it back into ② at next month's meeting
- Ways to cut the effort e.g. Split H into 10 customers at a time, and it becomes medium effort and can go in do now next month
⑮ Owner, deadline, check, signal
| Owner and deadline | Check after 1 month | How to check | Signal and fallback | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| D Same-day quotes | e.g. Sales, the 20th this month | e.g. Share of quotes returned the same day | e.g. About half now. Count on the intake sheet | e.g. Keep going once it is above 80%. If nothing has started after a month, go back to (board⑦) |
| A Proof sheet | e.g. Prepress, the 25th this month | e.g. Number of reprints | e.g. 5 last month. Count from the work log | e.g. Keep going at 2 or fewer. If it does not drop, go back to (board⑤) and review the impact level |
| G Shelf colors | e.g. Delivery, end of this month | e.g. Time spent looking for paper | e.g. Time 5 searches and take the average minutes | e.g. Keep going if search time halves. If the shelves run short, pass it to (board⑭) |
Task board contents
Collect ideas 16 items
Align the scale
On page 1 of the board, gather last time's results and this time's ideas and align what high, medium, and low mean for impact and effort. With a shared scale, discussion lines up when you place ideas on page 2. Press Ctrl+F (⌘F on Mac) and type "3/4" to jump to page 3.
Write last results
On board ①, write how the 3 you picked last time turned out, the purpose this time, and who is attending. If it is your first time, leave the results blank, and it is done once the purpose and attendees are written.
Put ideas on notes
Write the ideas from meetings, customer comments, and problems on the floor on boards ②–④, one idea per note. Label them A, B, C, and it is done when everyone's ideas are on notes.
Define the scales
In the table on board ⑤, write what high, medium, and low impact and effort mean, with numbers and an example, one row each. Read the 4 spots on board ⑥, and it is done when everyone nods.
Place on two axes
On page 2 of the board, place every collected idea on the payoff matrix and discuss only the ideas whose ratings split. This parent task is the heart of the meeting and takes the most time.
Place all ideas
Move the notes from boards ②–④ into the 4 spots on board ⑦, checking them against the scale on board ⑤. It is done when every note is in a spot.
Copy split ideas
Copy ideas whose impact estimates split onto board ⑧ and ideas whose effort estimates split onto board ⑨, and line up the reasons of those who rated high and low. It is done when every split idea is copied.
Decide spot and why
Discuss the ideas on boards ⑧ and ⑨ for up to 10 minutes each and write the decided spot and reason on board ⑩. It is done when every split idea has a spot.
Pick this month's 3
On page 3 of the board, compare the do-now ideas in a table and vote to narrow them to this month's 3. The ideas you did not pick and why are recorded too, so they feed next month's meeting.
Copy the candidates
Write each idea placed in do now on board ⑦ and each idea decided as do now on board ⑩ in its own row on board ⑪, and fill in the impact level, the effort level, and whether it can finish this month.
Vote, 3 votes each
On the rows of board ⑪, each person places up to 3 red circle stamps. Count the votes in each row by eye and write the numbers. It is done when the top 3 by votes are clear.
Write why you chose
On board ⑫, write the 3 picked and why, and the ideas set aside and why. If ideas tie on votes, add that you chose the one with less effort.
Hand 3 to owners
On page 4 of the board, decide the first step, owner, and deadline for each of the 3, and what to check after 1 month. Track the decided 3 by moving them from the This month's 3 column to the In progress column of the task board.
Write first steps
On board ⑬, put the 3 and the shared prep on the branches, and add one line on each branch for the first step you can take tomorrow. Line up the plan-it ideas on board ⑭.
Set owners and dates
In the table on board ⑮, write the owner, deadline, and what to check after 1 month for each of the 3. It is done when all 3 rows have an owner and a deadline.
Decide by signals
At the meeting a month later, read the signal and fallback column on board ⑮ and decide whether to keep going, change, or stop each of the 3. It is done when the result is written on board ① of the next round.