Team & People
How to Run a Consensus Game for Beginners: Rank Alone, Agree as a Team, Compare with a Reference
Beginner | 4 whiteboard pages · Task board: 5 columns (4 parent tasks, 12 subtasks)
Beginner: No technical terms. Just answer the whiteboard's questions, following the examples, and it takes shape.
How to run a consensus game: rank alone, agree as a team, then compare with a reference.
Read more Show less
Plan on 5-8 people and 60 minutes; you leave with a way to decide without a majority vote and one idea for your next meeting. Rank six items whose answer shows in workplace records, such as last month's busiest counter errands. The facilitator builds the reference ranking from the records and does not rank. It is a yardstick, not a single right answer. Add the rank gaps by hand: a team gap below the individual ones means talking helped.
Unlike a vote or an average, the team ranking is set by talking through reasons until everyone accepts it. Each person may circle up to two ranks they cannot accept, and you talk until the circles are gone. Time: 10 min to explain, 10 alone, 25 as a team, 15 to reflect.
The whiteboard has 4 pages: topic and rules, rank alone, agree as a team, try at a meeting. The task board has 5 columns, 4 parent tasks matching the pages, and 12 subtasks.
Once you have a free account, you can copy this template from the marketplace
Whiteboard preview
Read the whiteboard text as plain text
Consensus Game Team Agreement Board
How to use (4 pages): ① Write the goal on page 1 and read the topic and rules (boards①–⑧) → ② Rank alone, in silence, on page 2 (boards⑨⑩) → ③ Set one team ranking and add the gaps from the reference on page 3 (boards⑪⑫) → ④ Compare gaps and choose what to try at the next meeting on page 4 (boards⑬–⑰)
1/4 Get the topic and rules
① Goal, time, people (start here)
- Goal e.g. Turn a meeting where the loudest voice wins into one where everyone's reasons are heard
- Time e.g. A monthly 60-minute study session (10 to explain, 10 alone, 25 as a team, 15 to reflect)
- People e.g. Six staff from the counter and sales teams (aged 20s to 50s). The facilitator is the study session lead and does not rank
② Decided by a vote (a current pain point)
- e.g. We picked the year-end party venue by a show of hands and two people were left unhappy
- e.g. We set the counter shift schedule by the most popular plan and never asked for reasons
- e.g. It was decided 4 to 2 and the two people's worries were never recorded
- How to fill in: write when, what, and how it was decided in one line
③ Decided by the loudest voice (a current pain point)
- e.g. One comment from a veteran decided where the flyers go in the store
- e.g. A younger colleague had an opinion but did not say it in the meeting
- e.g. Later, in the break room, someone said they had actually disagreed
- How to fill in: describe the scene, not who was at fault
④ Carried over again (a current pain point)
- e.g. How to take appointments for customers coming to the branch has gone undecided for three months
- e.g. The same discussion repeats until time runs out
- e.g. Nobody was in charge of deciding, so it moved to the next meeting
- How to fill in: add how many times it was carried over
⑤ Topic and rules (read and check)
- Topic (six items to reorder) e.g. The order of last month's busiest counter errands. Errand 1 = change of address, errand 2 = passbook update, errand 3 = bank transfer, errand 4 = term deposit, errand 5 = card reissue, errand 6 = tax and utility bill payment
- Reference ranking (the facilitator builds it) The facilitator counts the errands in the counter records and ranks them from most to fewest as the reference ranking. The facilitator does not rank and keeps the reference hidden until page 3. The reference comes from records and is not a single right answer e.g. Bank transfer 182, tax and utility bills 140, passbook update 95 (counts are made up)
- Rules No majority vote, no average, no drawing lots. Talk through reasons until everyone can say "I can accept this ranking." Each person may circle up to two ranks they cannot accept; keep talking until the circles are gone
- How to work out the gap For each errand, take the gap between your rank and the reference rank and add the six by hand. Smaller is closer to the reference (0 to 18). If the team's gap is smaller than the individual gaps, the discussion improved the answer
⑥ Phrases for asking reasons (use in the discussion)
- e.g. Why did you rank it that way?
- e.g. Tell us about a moment you saw at the counter
- e.g. Where did you see that number?
⑦ Phrases for a different view (use in the discussion)
- e.g. I ranked it differently. My reason is the month-end queue
- e.g. From the view of the customers I visit in sales, the order changes
- How to fill in: repeat their view once before you give yours
⑧ Phrases to check before deciding (use in the discussion)
- e.g. Is there anyone who cannot accept this ranking?
- e.g. Which errands still have circles?
- e.g. Let's record the opinions we did not take in ⑫
2/4 Rank the items alone
⑨ Rank the six errands in ⑤ alone (write in silence)
| Person A | Person B | Person C | Person D | Person E | Person F | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Errand 1 | e.g. 4 | e.g. 6 | e.g. 3 | e.g. 5 | e.g. 6 | e.g. 4 |
| Errand 2 | e.g. 2 | e.g. 1 | e.g. 4 | e.g. 2 | e.g. 4 | e.g. 3 |
| Errand 3 | e.g. 1 | e.g. 2 | e.g. 2 | e.g. 3 | e.g. 1 | e.g. 2 |
| Errand 4 | e.g. 5 | e.g. 3 | e.g. 6 | e.g. 1 | e.g. 2 | e.g. 1 |
| Errand 5 | e.g. 6 | e.g. 5 | e.g. 5 | e.g. 6 | e.g. 5 | e.g. 6 |
| Errand 6 | e.g. 3 | e.g. 4 | e.g. 1 | e.g. 4 | e.g. 3 | e.g. 5 |
| Gap (fill in later) | e.g. 4 | e.g. 8 | e.g. 8 | e.g. 8 | e.g. 6 | e.g. 8 |
⑩ Reasons for ⑨ (one line each for top and bottom)
- Why you ranked it top e.g. Person A: Bank transfer first. I see a transfer line form every month-end
- Why you ranked it bottom e.g. Person A: Card reissue last. I have handled only a handful in the past six months
- Errand you are unsure about e.g. Person A: I could not decide whether passbook updates or tax payments are more common
3/4 Agree on one team ranking
⑪ Team ranking from ⑨⑩ (2 circles each)
| Counter only | Same people monthly | Many customers | Team rank | Reference (gap) | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Errand 1 | e.g. △ Can also be done by mail | e.g. × About once a year | e.g. △ Only people who moved | e.g. 5 | e.g. 5 (gap 0) |
| Errand 2 | e.g. △ A machine can do it | e.g. △ Comes on pension paydays (every 2 months) | e.g. ○ Many | e.g. 2 | e.g. 3 (gap 1) |
| Errand 3 | e.g. △ ATMs can do it | e.g. ○ Monthly payments | e.g. ○ Very many | e.g. 1 | e.g. 1 (gap 0) |
| Errand 4 | e.g. ○ Mostly at the counter | e.g. × Only at maturity | e.g. △ Some people | e.g. 4 | e.g. 4 (gap 0) |
| Errand 5 | e.g. ○ Counter only | e.g. × Rare | e.g. × Few | e.g. 6 | e.g. 6 (gap 0) |
| Errand 6 | e.g. △ Can pay at a store too | e.g. ○ Comes every month | e.g. ○ Many | e.g. 3 | e.g. 2 (gap 1) |
| Total gap | — | — | — | — | e.g. 2 (individuals 4 to 8) |
⑫ Opinions taken and not taken, with reasons
- Opinion taken and why e.g. We took Person B's point that many people come for tax payments every month-end and put it 3rd. Recalling the records made it convincing
- Opinion not taken and why e.g. We did not take Person F's suggestion to rank term deposits higher. The amounts are big but the count is not
- Errand that differed from the reference e.g. We ranked passbook updates 2nd but the reference has it 3rd. The crowd on pension paydays left too strong an impression
4/4 Try it at a work meeting
⑬ Compare the gap totals of ⑨ and ⑪
- Individual gap totals e.g. 4, 8, 8, 8, 6, 8. The smallest is Person A's 4
- Team gap total e.g. 2. Smaller than the best individual total of 4
- What we learned e.g. Nobody beat the team. Talking brought in reasons no one person had thought of
⑭ What went well in the discussion
- e.g. Everyone gave their reasons at least once
- e.g. Placing a circle made it easier to put an objection into words
- e.g. The sales staff's view exposed a counter assumption
- How to fill in: use facts and numbers
⑮ Where the discussion got stuck
- e.g. One person kept talking and the younger staff went quiet
- e.g. Time ran short and we wanted to decide fast at the end
- e.g. Someone said an average would be fine
- How to fill in: describe the scene without blaming anyone
⑯ Tips for work meetings
- e.g. Hear each person's reasons before deciding
- e.g. Ask people who disagree to place a circle
- e.g. Put the opinions we did not take in the minutes too
- How to fill in: write it so you can use it as is in the next meeting
⑰ What to try at the next meeting (last column is the signal)
| What to try | Owner | Date | Signal (keep/change/drop) | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Next meeting | e.g. Ask for reasons with the ⑥ phrases before deciding | e.g. Branch manager | e.g. December in-store meeting | e.g. Keep if two or more reasons for objecting come up |
| Meeting after that | e.g. Place up to two circles each before any vote | e.g. Counter lead | e.g. January in-store meeting | e.g. Change if the meeting runs 10+ min over |
| If nothing changes | e.g. Choose the phrases again | e.g. Study session facilitator | e.g. The week after the 2nd meeting | e.g. If talk is unchanged after 2 tries, drop it and return to (boards⑥–⑧) |
Task board contents
Prep 16 items
Get topic and rules
On page 1, write the purpose of the session and how meetings decide things today, then read the topic and rules together. The facilitator builds the reference ranking before the session. Press Ctrl+F (⌘F on Mac) and type 3/4 to jump to page 3.
Goal, time, people
On the three notes of board①, write the purpose, the time split, and who takes part. Done when all three are filled in.
Build the reference
Before the session, the facilitator counts the six errands in board⑤ from the counter records and writes the order, most to fewest, on a separate sheet as the reference ranking. Done when the sheet exists. Participants do not see it until page 3.
Add habits, phrases
On boards②–④, add one way of deciding that caused trouble in your meetings, one per board, and on boards⑥–⑧ write one phrase per person to use in the discussion.
Rank alone
On page 2, each person silently ranks the six errands in the topic and writes reasons. Writing without talking means everyone arrives on page 3 with a view of their own.
Read the 6 errands
Read the six errands in the topic of board⑤ aloud and make sure everyone understands the words the same way. Done when no errand is unclear.
Rank in silence
In your own column of board⑨, write ranks 1 to 6 for the six errands. Done when you finish in 10 minutes with no repeated rank.
Write your reasons
On board⑩, write one line each on why you put one errand top and one bottom, and add one you were unsure about.
Agree as a team
On page 3, bring your individual rankings and reasons together and set one team ranking by talking about three criteria. This is the heart of the session and takes the most time.
Set the team ranking
In the three criteria columns of board⑪, write discussion notes for each errand, then set the team ranking column. Each person may place up to two circles on ranks they cannot accept. Done when the circles are gone.
Add reference gaps
The facilitator reads out the reference ranking. Copy it into the last column of board⑪ and write the gap for each errand. Add the gaps by hand and write the total in the last row, and also write each person's gap total in the last row of board⑨.
Log opinions taken
On board⑫, write one opinion you took and one you did not, each with its reason, and note any errand that differed from the reference.
Try at a meeting
On page 4, compare individual and team gaps and turn the discussion tips into something to try at your next meeting. This parent task ends when you decide whether to continue after trying.
Compare gap totals
On board⑬, copy the individual gap totals and the team gap total, and write whether the team total is smaller than the best individual total.
Write tips and tests
On boards⑭–⑯, write what went well, where you got stuck, and tips for work meetings, then fill in the table on board⑰ with what to try, who owns it, and the date.
Decide by the signal
After trying it at a meeting, read the signal column of board⑰, decide to keep, change, or drop, and add the words you chose to that column. If nothing changes after two tries, return to boards⑥–⑧ and choose your phrases again.