Business & Strategy
PPM Analysis for Beginners: Stars, Cash Cows, Question Marks, Dogs
Beginner | 2 whiteboard pages · Task board: 5 columns (4 parent tasks, 12 subtasks)
Beginner: No technical terms. Just answer the whiteboard's questions, following the examples, and it takes shape.
Anyone deciding which of several products or services to focus on opens this beginner template the first time they try PPM analysis (the BCG matrix). The whiteboard holds a four-quadrant matrix (market growth rate x relative share) for stars, cash cows, question marks, and dogs, two frames on the high/low lines, a 5x3 grid for each product's numbers, five allocation steps, and a frame for what to grow and cut. The task board has five columns from listing products to review, with four parent tasks, each split into three not-started subtasks. Even if you don't know PPM analysis, just list products, enter the numbers, place them in the quadrants, then follow each quadrant's playbook to land on an allocation. It suits individuals or small teams with several offerings, like a restaurant menu, courses, or side-income sources. Enter amounts in dollars and compare annual revenue and profit over the same period.
Once you have a free account, you can copy this template from the marketplace
Whiteboard preview
Read the whiteboard text as plain text
PPM Analysis Starter Board
How to use: (1) Write products and numbers in the entry grid (board4) → (2) Check how to set the high/low lines (boards2-3) → (3) Place products in the four quadrants (board1) → (4) Decide the allocation using each quadrant's playbook (board5) → (5) Note what to grow and cut (board6)
1. The PPM/BCG Matrix (Market Growth Rate x Relative Share)
Vertical axis: Market growth rate (top = the market itself is growing) / Horizontal axis: Relative share (right = selling better than competitors)
- Question Mark (growing market, not No. 1) The playbook is to choose. It's a growing market so you can't ignore it, but you can't invest in all of them either. Pick one to invest in fully and pass on the rest. e.g. Soup subscription (growth +20%, No. 3, annual revenue $4,000, annual profit $400)
- Star (growing market, you're No. 1) The playbook is to grow it. Put in the most money and time to defend the No. 1 spot. When market growth stops, it becomes a cash cow on its own. e.g. Fried chicken bento (growth +15%, No. 1, annual revenue $16,000, annual profit $3,200)
- Dog (market not growing, you're not No. 1) The playbook is to pull back. Decide to scale down or end it, with a date. Redirect the freed-up time and money to your stars. e.g. Takeout bread (growth -3%, No. 4, annual revenue $2,700, annual profit $130)
- Cash Cow (market not growing, you're No. 1) The playbook is to protect it. Cut the effort it takes and lock in the profit. The profit from here becomes the funding for your stars and question marks. e.g. Daily lunch special (growth +2%, No. 1, annual revenue $24,000, annual profit $6,000)
2. Setting the High/Low Line (Market Growth Rate)
- e.g. Check whether the whole market grew this past year. +10% or more goes "high" (top).
- No stats? Use the change in customer count or inquiries over the past year instead.
- Look at the market's own growth, not your own sales. If you grew but the market didn't, that's "low."
- When unsure, go "low." Overestimating means overinvesting in a market that isn't growing.
3. Setting the Left/Right Line (Relative Share)
- e.g. Estimate your rank against the top seller in the same market and category.
- No. 1 goes "high" (right); No. 2 or below all go "low" (left). The exact rank doesn't matter.
- Compare against outside competitors, not your own sales mix. Mix this up and everything reads "high."
- If you don't know your rank, compare order or booking counts for similar products as a stand-in.
4. Per-Product Entry Grid (fill in numbers, then place in quadrants)
| Market growth | Relative share | Annual revenue | Annual profit | Quadrant | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| e.g. Fried chicken bento | High (+15%/yr) | High (No. 1) | $16,000 | $3,200 | Star |
| e.g. Daily lunch special | Low (+2%/yr) | High (No. 1) | $24,000 | $6,000 | Cash Cow |
| e.g. Soup subscription | High (+20%/yr) | Low (No. 3) | $4,000 | $400 | Question Mark |
5. 5 Steps for Deciding the Money and Time Allocation
- Step 1 - Star Grow it (put in the most money and time) e.g. Put $270/month in ads and 8 hours/week into the fried chicken bento.
- Step 2 - Cash Cow Protect it (cut effort, keep the profit) e.g. Standardize the daily lunch special's prep and cut it to 1 hour/week.
- Step 3 - Question Mark Choose (decide invest-fully or pass, one by one) e.g. Try the soup subscription for just 3 months, then stop if it's not working.
- Step 4 - Dog Pull back (decide to scale down or end it) e.g. End the takeout bread this month and free up 5 hours/week.
- Step 5 - Total Split money and time so they total 100% e.g. Money: 50% star, 30% cash cow, 20% question mark, 0% dog. Time: of 10 hours/week, 8 to the star, 1 to the cash cow, 1 to the question mark.
6. What You Decided (Grow / Cut)
- What to grow (stars, plus any question marks you're investing in) e.g. Fried chicken bento - raise ads from $130/month to $270/month, and hours from 3/week to 8/week (using the 5 hours/week freed up by dropping takeout bread) Owner: ____
- What to cut or stop (dogs, plus question marks you're passing on) e.g. Takeout bread - end it this month, redirect the freed 5 hours/week to fried chicken bento Owner: ____ / Next re-entry and re-placement date: __/__
Task board contents
List products 16 items
List products
The first step of lining up what you'll analyze. If the scope varies here, later comparisons won't hold up, so match the granularity before moving on.
List what you sell
List every product or service you currently charge for. Include ongoing ones even with zero sales. Done once everything is listed.
Align count units
Decide whether you're counting by single item or by series, and keep it consistent. Mixed units make revenue impossible to compare, so settle this first.
Narrow to 4-8 items
Group items with tiny sales together to reach 4-8 items. The entry grid (board 4) has 3 example rows - just add more rows below in the same format if you have more.
Gather the numbers
This builds the grounds for placing items in the quadrants. Placing by feel changes the conclusion, so lock in amounts and rank first.
Revenue & profit
Write each product's past year's revenue and profit in dollars. Done once you've subtracted cost of goods and labor to get what's left.
Check market growth
Check how much that product's market grew over the past year. If no stats exist, use the change in customer count or inquiries instead.
Rank vs competitors
Estimate your rank within the same market area and category. Whether you're No. 1 decides the left/right position, so make sure you can judge at least that.
Place in quadrants
This transfers the numbers you gathered onto the board. Recording why you placed something matters more than the position itself, for later review.
Set high/low lines
For market growth and relative share, decide first where the line for "high" starts. Done once you set the line before placing products.
Place each product
Place each product into the four quadrants exactly per the grid's numbers. If unsure, place it on the "low" side to avoid overrating it.
Note your reasons
Add a short reason for each placement. That way, when you re-place items in three months, you can spot right away what changed your judgment.
Decide & execute
The final part that turns analysis into action. Decide what to grow and what to cut at the same time, keeping the total at 100%.
Pick what to grow
Set concrete money and time for stars and any question marks you've decided to invest in. Done once you've written the amount and hours per week.
Pick what to cut
For dogs and question marks you're passing on, decide whether to scale down or end them, plus a date. Also decide where the freed-up time goes.
Set review date
Set a date three months out to re-enter numbers and re-place items, and note who's responsible. This becomes the next starting point, so lock in the date.